Free prep sheet for engineering managers
How to answer the 4 review questions, handle "what could you have done better," and ask for impact instead of a title. From a former Director of Engineering who made this mistake herself.
You'll also get my occasional emails on leadership for women in tech. Unsubscribe anytime.
If you only remember one thing
The trap, the reframe, and a starter line for each one.
How to be honest without leaving a negative impression that sticks.
Why a title isn't enough, and how to propose a stretch initiative instead.
How to bring what your team and peers say about you into the room.
When I wanted to become a Director, I walked into my review with a list of everything I had done as a manager. It proved I was good at my role. It didn't prove I was ready for the next one.
Years later, as a Director of Engineering at DigitalOcean, I sat on the other side of the table. The managers who were ready for more came prepared, were honest about their blind spots, knew what they wanted, and showed impact beyond their role, without being asked.
This prep sheet is what I wish I had known back then. It's also what I now walk my coaching clients through before every review season.
Limor Bergman Gross, PCC. Executive and leadership coach for women in tech, and host of the From a Woman to a Leader podcast.
How should an engineering manager prepare for a performance review?
Prepare like you're presenting a case, not filling in a form. Separate what you delivered in your role from the impact you made beyond it, name one or two honest growth areas and what you're already doing about them, and come with a proposed plan for next year that shows you can operate at the next level.
How do I answer "what could you have done better" in a performance review?
Pick one or two real things, not five. Use this structure: what you'd do differently, what you learned, and what you're already doing about it. Honest self-evaluation is a leadership signal. What matters is what comes after the admission.
Should I ask for a promotion in my performance review?
Ask for an opportunity, not just a title. At the manager-to-Director stage, a promotion often depends on a role opening up, which is outside your control. Asking to lead a specific, visible initiative shows you can already operate at the next level, and that's what opens up possibilities.
Should I include feedback from peers in my self-review?
Yes. Proactively asking the people you manage, peers, and stakeholders for feedback, and bringing both strengths and growth areas into the review, shows your manager you care how others experience your work. It's often stronger than anything you can say about yourself.
Who created the prep sheet?
Limor Bergman Gross, PCC, an executive and leadership coach for women in tech and former Director of Engineering at DigitalOcean with 20+ years in tech. She hosts the From a Woman to a Leader podcast.
That's exactly what I help engineering managers figure out. Book a free promotion strategy call and we'll look at where you are and what your ask could be.
Book a free promotion strategy call