It took me 10 years to move from first-line manager to Director of Engineering. One of my biggest mistakes along the way was walking into my reviews with a list of everything I'd done. It proved I was good at my job. It didn't prove I was ready for the next one.
In this solo episode, I share what I'd do differently, and what I saw from the other side of the table when I was the Director reading those reviews.
You'll learn:
- Why performance reviews matter more than you think (hint: calibration)
- What to do when you hear ”you're not ready yet”
- What ”ready for more” actually looked like to me as a Director, and why tenure isn't it
- How to answer the 4 review questions, including ”what could you have done better?”
- Why you should ask for impact, not a title
- A bonus most managers skip: bringing peer feedback into your review
Free Performance Review Prep Sheet: https://limorbergman.com/free-performance-review-prep-sheet-for-engineering-managers/
Want help figuring out what to ask for?
Book a promotion strategy call: https://calendly.com/limorbergman/promotion-strategy-call
Chapters:
0:00 Why my list wasn't enough
0:34 Welcome
1:32 Why reviews matter: calibration
2:25 ”You're not ready yet”
5:05 What ”ready for more” looked like from the Director's chair
6:08 The 4 review questions
6:30 Question 1: What did you accomplish?
9:15 Question 2: What could you have done better?
12:57 Question 3: What will you focus on next year?
15:24 Question 4: What feedback do you have for your manager?
16:41 Ask for impact, not a title
17:47 Bonus: peer feedback
18:53 The one thing to take away
